You won't be able to resist this incredible recipe for Eggnog Fudge. This rich and creamy fudge has the perfect balance of spice, sweetness and smoothness.
This recipe for Eggnog Fudge comes from one of my favourite bloggers Recipe Girl. I had a few of my own adaptations like using a fresh vanilla bean and  just a pinch of ground cloves.  I am a firm believer, if you are going to indulge your sweet tooth, make sure you do so with fine quality ingredients. Using fine quality chocolate will definitely elevate the flavour of your fudge. The top of the fudge was sprinkled with a Holiday Spice Infused sugar I had bought a gourmet food store, but you can also use a bit of nutmeg.
Fudge is a terrific Holiday treat that also makes a great gift. Make a few batches to keep on hand as this fudge freezes great. Eggnog Fudge so tasty and this recipe will make you wish they sold eggnog year round.
Eggnog Fudge
Ingredients
- 2 cups sugar granulated
- ½ cup butter
- ¾ cup eggnog
- 10 ounces white chocolate chopped into pieces
- 1 7oz jar marshmallow creme
- ¼ teaspoon ground nutmeg
- â…› teaspoon ground cloves
- 1 vanilla bean pod seeds scrapped out 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract will also work
Instructions
- Line a 8 inch square pan with foil. Lightly butter the foil.
- Combine sugar, butter and eggnog in a heavy saucepan.
- Bring to boil over medium heat, stirring constantly. Continue to cook at a rolling boil, stirring constantly for additional 8-10 minutes or until candy thermometer reaches temperature of 235º F.
- Remove from heat, immediately stir in chopped white chocolate, nutmeg, cloves and vanilla bean seeds.
- Stir vigorously until chocolate is melted.
- Next add the marshmallow creme, stir vigorously until well combined
- Pour into prepared pan, spreading evenly.
- Sprinkle top with some nutmeg or holiday spice infused sugar.
- Cool to room temperature, then cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate until set. (3-4 hours)
- Store in refrigerator in airtight container.
Notes
This fudge recipe that will be getting rave reviews, so make plenty to give to family and friends.
More great fudge recipe you'll love Candy Cane Fudge and   Cookies and Cream Fudge
Helen Pickel says
Beat fudge tis year!
Laureen King says
Thanks Helen, it is pretty tasty!
Liz says
It says marshmallow creme is in the ingredients, but I didn't see in the recipe instructions where it gets added. I added it when I added the white chocolate chips. It seems that may have been the right place to add it in to the sauce pan. Super yummy!
Laureen King says
Thanks Liz for catching that, I have corrected the recipe. I must have been in la la land when I wrote out the instructions.
Diane says
You were in fudge land..thanks for the recipe.
Alice @ hip foodie mom says
I've never tried eggnog. Will have to start with this!
Laureen King says
Hi Alice, I don't like eggnog straight up, but I love it in baking and mixed drinks
Edward Kowalski says
I've seen this same recipe on many sites, but I've also read in all the comments that some people have trouble with the fudge not ever getting firm. How can we guarantee that the fudge will set up properly and not remain overly soft?
Laureen King says
Most of the recipes that have marshmallow fluff in them will be softer, but I don't find this recipe overly soft.
Lisa Henderson says
Can this be frozen and if so - how long?
Laureen King says
Hi Lisa, I have not froze this recipe, but cheesecakes freeze quite well and usually best if not more than a month.
Pamela Candiliere says
Would the eggnog fudge be good with regular chocolate chips? Thank you
Laureen King says
I think the chocolate chips would overwhelm the flavour of the eggnog.
Jill says
Okay, I normally am not into marshmallow fudges, but dang! This is gooood. Every year I make a ridiculous number of different kinds of fudge. So glad I gave this one a try. It is my new favorite. I followed the directions exactly, and it was perfect. I will definitely make this every year when I go on my fudge frenzies. Yum!
Laureen King says
Thank you Jill, it is one of my favourite fudge recipes as well, but way too addictive lol.
Jesse Winehouse says
Hello,
Am looking to make a few different types of dessert for a gathering in a few weeks. I made a batch of both the eggnog and your candy cane peppermint fudge. (Both delicious by the way!) but was looking to make it in advance to save time. Would you happened to know the shelf life for both fudges? Thank you.
Robin says
Hi I don't have any Vanilla bean can I use vanilla extract in it's place & if so how much would you suggest ? Thank you. This sounds delicious !
Laureen King says
Hi Robin, absolutely you can substitute a teaspoon of pure vanilla extra. Enjoy.
Robin says
Thank you !
Rigbyblue says
Made this for the first time and it’s wonderful! I had 11 oz of white chocolate so used it all. I also wanted it to have true eggnog flavor so I used rum and brandy instead of vanilla and OMG! My husband who doesn’t like fudge just had his third piece! Thank you so much for this recipe! It will be a Christmas tradition from now on!
Laureen King says
So glad you enjoyed the recipe, I think I'm going to be trying the rum and brandy. Sounds yummy. Have a very Merry Christmas.
CAROLE Osborn says
How do you get 49 servings from this recipe
Laureen King says
7 x 7 slices
Carol merritt says
Would so love the chickpea curry recipe. Could you send it to my email box. Can’t seem to find the recipe.
Laureen King says
Here's the link to the recipe Carol, enjoy https://www.artandthekitchen.com/chickpea-curry/
Janet says
I did something wrong and have to give this 3 stars even though it tastes great when I scrape the pan. I followed the directions exactly and after stiring 8 min. and testing at 235F and adding the white chocolate it was impossible to stir and way too dry so got out the eggnog and added about 2T more. Then it could be stirred but became very gritty and lumpy. So I took the hand beater out and tried to get the lumps out. Got some but not all. I have poured it into the pan and will have it set. Was there a misprint. It says cook time 4 min. but instructions say bring to boil and cook 8-10. I am not a chef so could adding cold eggnog to a mixture that was hot caused the lumpy issue? The taste could be a 5 star if I can figure out what I did wrong and how to correct. Not sure I can package this up to give as a hostess gift with the texture. Will have to see what happens after 3-4 hrs. in frig. if it seems gritty.
Laureen King says
Hi Janet, sorry for the delayed response. I think it may have got gritty because of adding the extra eggnog, which probably seized up the chocolate. Cooking time is until temperature of 235F, about 8-10 minutes. If temperature went higher than that it could have caused the problem. I just made this fudge and it turned out very creamy, so I do hope you try it again. Also did you use pure white chocolate, not those wafer things?